The charred human bones they found in her kitchen stove that warm September day in 1893 were never identified, but Lizzie Halliday had already killed at least five other people and would kill again. Born in County Antrim, Ireland in 1863 and christened Eliza Margaret McNally, she was called Maggie until the newspapers named her Lizzie for Lizzie Borden, who had been tried for taking an ax to her parents the previous August. The name stuck; she would never be Maggie again.